Boy to Girl to Man writing exercise
- Due Sep 23, 2021 by 11:59am
- Points 10
- Submitting a text entry box or a file upload
- Available Sep 21, 2021 at 12am - Sep 23, 2021 at 11:59am
READ ALL THE INSTRUCTIONS PRIOR TO WORKING ON THIS ASSIGNMENT. FAILURE TO FOLLOW THE DIRECTIONS PRECISELY WILL RESULT IN A LOWER GRADE OR NO GRADE.
And, it reduces the number of emails I will get asking questions that are answered here.
Please upgrade your submission to 18 pt. type font prior to submitting this. I frequently grade them on my phone and the larger type font makes it sooooo much easier.
Please create a single submission which answers all the questions noted below in a single document. Ten in the first part, 3 in the last section. I expect personal and unique answers from each student, not a group effort. You only need to submit one to three lines per question. Please do not repeat the questions in your document, simply answer by number, i.e. 1. It will be subjected to plagiarism testing upon submission, copying over the questions and/or repeated answers from different students will be flagged.
Minimum 200 words. 18 pt. type font.
Watch the video, and then discuss it in small discussion groups.
Then complete this writing submission by the due date.
CONTENT QUESTIONS FROM THE VIDEO
1. What were the real names of the people involved? Explain what happened to the family, from the time of the accident to the time that this video was produced. (This story is told in segments throughout the video.)
2. What is the basic position of Dr. John Money? Why did he do what he did in the twin’s case? What is meant by “gender neutrality”?
3. What is the position of Dr. Milton Diamond? What role did he play in the twins case? What does he believe causes gender identity? (May need to look this one up, Wiki, Google, etc., he does not appear in the video)
4. What have various studies on the use of testosterone and the brains of rats, “normal” men and women, and transsexuals shown? (They occur throughout the video, or do some searching)
THOUGHT AND DISCUSSION QUESTIONS FROM THE VIDEO AND READINGS
1. Give a basic summary of what the video showed and your immediate reaction to it. Compare your reaction to that of some other students in this class.
2. How should the outcome of this one case affect standard medical practice, including the treatment of intersex babies? Can we learn a significant lesson from a single case?
3. What would you do if a similar accident happened to your baby boy?
4. What are the implications of the John/Joan case for ever achieving a society with sexual equality, or of creating Kate Bornstein’s vision of a “no-gender” world (again, you may have to do some outside research)?
5. What are the roles of nature and of nurture in the development of our gender roles? Why should we care?